HOME > NEWSROOM > ARTICLES > Will For-Profits Suffer Legal Loss?

Will For-Profits Suffer Legal Loss?

Hobby LobbyWhen a Supreme Court justice issued an order the day after Christmas, it gave us a window into a crucial religious liberty issue that has been brewing for some time. The question is whether a closely-held, for-profit religious organization can exercise religious freedom rights.

On December 26, Justice Sonia Sotomayor denied a request for a temporary injunction that had been filed by Hobby Lobby Stores, a family-owned for-profit company that has been fighting to be exempted from the strictures of the ObamaCare/HHS mandate that requires all employers to provide insurance access to abortion medications for their employees. The owners of Hobby Lobby are objecting to that mandate on religious grounds, but Sotomayor wrote that “[t]his Court has not previously addressed” the issue of closely-held, for-profit companies possessing religious liberty rights, although the High Court has ruled that commercial businesses do have other rights within the First Amendment genus, such as in the free speech realm. In the HHS mandate cases, federal judges have side-stepped the precise legal issue; instead ruling in the cases of both Domino’s Pizza and Tyndale House Publishing that they have legal “standing” to raise religious objections in their lawsuits.

The Supreme Court will eventually have to address this issue as it is a river with countless tributaries. Take as an example ENDA (Employment Nondiscrimination Act), the bill that would make it difficult or impossible for many Christian organizations to turn down homosexuals in hiring decisions unless strong religious liberty exemptions are built into it. NRB has opposed ENDA for that very reason. In my past testimony before both the House and the Senate, I pointed out the “exemption” in ENDA is similar to language already tested in one federal case, and the court there ruled that a closely-held commercial business could not enforce the religious beliefs of its owner. If the Supreme Court takes this issue up and decides wrongly, then a host of for-profit religious organizations will be without any semblance of religious freedom, including broadcasting networks, bookstores, adoption agencies, hospitals, and mental health counseling centers, to name just a few.

The “corporate status” of organizations is often described as a legal fiction, though those various corporate categories have been created for sound policy and precedential reasons. Nevertheless, to say that huge commercial organizations can possess free speech rights but that family-owned businesses cannot possess comparable rights to religious conscience would seem to be a grotesque form of science fiction

By Craig Parshall
Senior Vice President & General Counsel, NRB
Director, John Milton Project for Free Speech

Click here to read more articles written by Craig Parshall.

Published: January 10, 2013

Latest News

NRB Calls for Defunding Planned Parenthood

As undercover videos have revealed key Planned Parenthood officials describing and negotiating the sale of aborted babies’ body parts, anger and scrutiny are increasing against the nation’s largest abortion organization.

Key Senator Expresses Concern with Supreme Court

Reflecting on the most recent Supreme Court term, Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Chuck Grassley (R-IA) this week said that the Court had a “very liberal bent this last term” and “more worrisome...

LPTV Highlighted at House Hearing

In a hearing featuring FCC Chairman Tom Wheeler and FCC Commissioner Ajit Pai, low power television (LPTV) received significant attention, particularly from Rep. Greg Walden (R-OR)...

Poll Explores Sentiment on Race Relations

A recent New York Times/CBS News poll showed that Americans generally have a negative impression of the state of race relations, noteworthy after tragedies around the nation, including at a church in Charleston, South Carolina.

Nominate Your Organization for a 2016 NRB Media Award!

NRB is currently accepting nominations for the 2016 Annual Media Awards and will be doing so until August 14, 2015. A long-standing hallmark of NRB, the awards program remains one of the association’s most valued traditions.

Life Without Limbs Celebrates 10th Anniversary, Launches ‘Stand Strong’

Life Without Limbs, the international non-profit ministry of speaker, author, and evangelist Nick Vujicic, recently marked its 10th anniversary and launched a new campaign in celebration.

Want to Make an Impact in DC? Join the NRB President’s Council

From among its membership, NRB has been building up a select group of strategic partners who wish to bolster the work of the association through additional commitments of time, support, and financial resources.

NRB Members: Highlight Your Organization in NRB Today – for Free!

We are soliciting descriptions about NRB members to feature in our weekly e-newsletter, NRB Today, and on the NRB.org website.

Senate Funders Take Aim at Agencies

Members of the Senate Appropriations Committee this week advanced legislation with provisions to restrict several agencies, particularly the FCC and the IRS.

Justice Alito Gives Insight into the Supreme Court

In a lengthy interview with Weekly Standard editor Bill Kristol, U.S. Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito provided insight into the high court’s procedures, commentary on recent cases, and some thoughts on baseball.

More News