HOME > NEWSROOM > ARTICLES > Whose Free Speech Is It Anyway?

Whose Free Speech Is It Anyway?

By Craig L. Parshall, Senior Vice President & General Counsel

John Milton Project for Free Speech, Craig ParshallLast week, I led a discussion at the National Press Club in Washington, DC, on the newest wave of censorship being perpetrated by Facebook, Apple, and Google against conservative and Christian viewpoints. Citizens holding those kinds of opinions are finding it more and more difficult to share them on the Internet platforms of those three media tech giants. That led to the next logical question among our panel of experts: what should we, or can we, do about it? The viewpoint discrimination practiced by those Web companies reminds me of a grade school boy who was part of our basketball group during recess. He was the proud owner of a yellow basketball that he brought to school every day. Each time we wanted to form a quick pick-up game on the playground, he would remind us that it was his basketball, and therefore he would make up the game rules. We would challenge him on that, but his answer was always the same: "Whose basketball is it, anyway?"

During the roundtable discussion sponsored last Thursday by our John Milton Project for Free Speech, we had three convincing testimonials about the phenomena of anti-conservative, anti-Christian censorship on the Web. Todd Starnes, a cultural commentator for FOX News, spoke to us about his own Facebook page. Todd tested the bounds of politically incorrect expression by posting that he was a fan of Paula Deen's cooking, a lover of Jesus-praising Gospel music, and proudly wears an NRA ball cap. Facebook shut his page down.

Gov. Mike Huckabee joined our discussion through a video message. He described how last year, during the Chick-fil-A controversy over same-sex marriage, he posted an invitation on his Facebook page for Americans who agreed with the traditional marriage position of Chick-fil-A's CEO, to show their support by frequenting that fast-food chain on a special appreciation day. Facebook shut him down too for some 12 hours, until millions of outraged citizens protested and Facebook relented.

Then there is the Manhattan Declaration – founded in part by the late Chuck Colson – an online statement of basic Christian conscience in matters of marriage, sanctity of life, and religious freedom. At our panel discussion, Eric Teetsel, who Colson hand-picked to run the project shortly before his death, described how the Declaration was approved by Apple and made available on its iTunes App Store for use on all iPhones. But when a cadre of gay rights activists protested, Apple removed the Declaration's iPhone app from its store without warning or notice.

During our Press Club discussion I shared our recent report, The Future of Free Speech, Freedom of Religion, and Free Press on Facebook, Google, Apple, etc. - a Current Assessment, where I also listed plenty of similar incidents of censorship by Google as well. Of course, we also heard words of caution from our other panelists – Adam Thierer, a respected media technology expert at George Mason University, and Trevor Burrus, a constitutional law pundit at the Cato Institute. They both reminded us that Facebook, Google, and Apple are private companies, and that the First Amendment does not constrain them legally. As private companies, they have the power to commit as much viewpoint censorship as they want. Beyond that, they indicated that those enterprises should enjoy the fruits of free enterprise, including the right to pursue their own policies that allow certain lawful opinions, but not others. Which brings us full-circle: what can, or should, be done about this shocking denial of – if not the "rights" of free speech, then certainly – the value of citizen free speech on Facebook, Google, and Apple?

As grade schoolers, my pals and I finally convinced the owner of the yellow basketball that he may own the ball, but the rest of us are necessary if the game is to be played. Yes, Facebook and their fellow Web Goliaths may own the right to control their social networking site, their Web innovations, and their iPhone systems. But without the messages, ideas, and opinions of ordinary citizens being posted, emailed, and shared on their sites, their companies couldn't exist. Whose "yellow basketball" is it? It is clearly theirs. But whose free speech is it, anyway? That, I would suggest, is ours.     

 

By Craig Parshall
Senior Vice President & General Counsel, National Religious Broadcasters
Director, John Milton Project for Free Speech     

Click here to read more articles written by Craig Parshall.

JMP

PHOTO ABOVE: Gov. Mike Huckabee shares via video his experience of having his pro-traditional marriage Facebook page taken down during the Chick-fil-A debate last year as event participants watch and listen. Up front, from left to right, are Todd Starnes, Host of FOX News & Commentary; Eric Teetsel, Executive Director of the Manhattan Declaration; Craig Parshall, Senior Vice President & General Counsel at NRB and Director of the John Milton Project; Adam Thierer, Senior Research Fellow with the Technology Policy Program at the Mercatus Center at George Mason University; and Trevor Burrus, Research Fellow at the Cato Institute’s Center for Constitutional Studies.

Published: October 10, 2013

Latest News

60,000 Shoebox Gifts Airlifted to Children Displaced by ISIS Militants in Northern Iraq

Samaritan’s Purse recently airlifted 60,000 Operation Christmas Child shoebox gifts to Northern Iraq, where displaced Iraqi kids have been stripped of their homes and most possessions.

Aaron Shust Partners with Radio Outlets for Holiday Promotions That Help People in Need

Dove-Award winning Aaron Shust is teaming with radio outlets across the country to help make Christmas a little more merry to those in need.

Christian Radio to Give Free College Tuition to Full Time Staff

Positive Alternative Radio (PAR) is providing its employees innovative new benefits that include access to higher education, time off for community service, and financial counseling.

CTVN Announces New Roku Channel

Cornerstone Network (CTVN) is now available on Roku TV and able to stream programming to viewers live and on demand.

Christmas Reflections in Washington

While end-of-year debates on government appropriations, military policy, tax provisions, judicial nominations, and other issues continue their rough road to resolution in this lame-duck session of Congress, Christmas is in the air in the nation’s capital.

FCC Rules Against Church on Closed Captioning

The FCC recently denied a church’s request for a waiver from closed captioning rules, shedding more light on the agency’s approach to determining what may truly be an “economically burdensome” situation.

Senator Promises a Bill Broader than ENDA

Senator Jeff Merkley (D-OR) announced this week that he intends to introduce legislation next year that will roll the controversial Employment Non-Discrimination Act (ENDA) into a broader...

White Paper Issued on Video Policy

Key leaders in the House Energy and Commerce Committee this week released a white paper on video policy as they continue their path toward a review and revamp the Communications Act.

NRB15 Worship Service on Wednesday, February 25, 2015; Open to the Public

The NRB Convention in 2015 will be a Monday-to-Thursday event rather than a Saturday-to-Tuesday event as in years before, but convention participants will still have an opportunity to worship together during the Wednesday evening worship service on February 25, 2015.

NRB to Host Regional Networking Event for Christian Film Pros, Jan. 10

Christian film professionals in the Baltimore, DC, and Richmond region are invited to attend a networking event next month at the NRB headquarters in Manassas, VA.

More News