HOME > NEWSROOM > ARTICLES > The Long Road to Religious Freedom

The Long Road to Religious Freedom

This term, the U.S. Supreme Court will be considering a religious liberty case so historic that the central issue winds like a distant road all the way back to a question raised 369 years ago: is government above God? NRB has begun preparations to file an amicus curiae (friend of the court) brief in an appeal that pits the U.S. Government against Hobby Lobby, owned by the Green family, as well as Conestoga Wood Specialties, another family-owned, faith-based company that has religious objections against being forced to provide abortion-inducing drug coverage in their health insurance plans. The insurance issue has arisen because, in implementing the Affordable Care Act (ACA), the Obama Administration has expressly refused to afford for-profit companies, even religiously-founded ones, an exemption from the abortion mandate provisions of the Act.

The tension between government and religious liberty was addressed by 17th Century Scottish pastor and divinity professor Samuel Rutherford in his treatise Lex Rex, published in 1644. Rutherford wrote that law should be above government, not the other way around, and that God, who is the only rightful force that “can lay a band of subjection on the conscience,” resides squarely above law. But the lawyers for the Obama Administration have it backwards. In court filings, they have argued that family-owned businesses, founded on spiritual principles, have no right to place God above government regulations, and cannot complain that their religious consciences have been coerced by ACA regulations -  coerced, in fact, to the tune of millions of dollars in penalties if the government’s view prevails (in the case of Hobby Lobby, a minimum of at least $26 million per year).

The government lawyers have argued that the ultimate issue is not about, at most, some “slight” burden on religious freedom; rather, they say, this appeal is really about “the interests of women who would bear the burden of accommodating the Greens’ personal religious beliefs.”

Which is the real issue here? Is it the fundamental rights of religious freedom of all Americans embedded in our history and recognized in our Bill of Rights? Or is it the rights of some women to have the government bully religious employers into facilitating their decision to prevent or end a pregnancy through mandated insurance coverage? When the Supreme Court affirmed “Obamacare” in 2012, even the justices who voted in the majority noted that the ACA could be in constitutional trouble if it “impermissibly ... interfered with the free exercise of religion.”

About 132 years after Rutherford’s Lex Rex, the Rev. John Witherspoon, a Scottish preacher and the mentor of James Madison, delivered a message just two months before he would join his Founding colleagues in signing the Declaration of Independence. He stated, “God grant that in America true religion and civil liberty may be inseparable and that the unjust attempts to destroy the one, may in the issue tend to the support and establishment of both.”

Perhaps we could add this postscript: God grant that these attempts of the government in our day to unjustly coerce the decisions of the people of faith might support and establish both the diligence of faith and the exercise of liberty in America.

By Craig Parshall
Senior Vice President & General Counsel, National Religious Broadcasters
Director, John Milton Project for Free Speech

Click here to read more articles written by Craig Parshall.

Published: December 12, 2013

Latest News

Constitutionality of Internet Authority Transfer Questioned

Four key Members of Congress are asking questions about the constitutionality of the Obama Administration’s plan to transition Internet oversight authority to a private stakeholder group.

Librarian of Congress Exits

Late last week, Librarian of Congress James H. Billington made a surprise announcement that he intended to resign his post effective September 30 rather than at the end of the year, as he had declared in June.

Commissioners Push for AM Radio

FCC Commissioner Ajit Pai (R) this week announced that he is continuing the push for a new FM translator application window solely for AM broadcasters.

New House Leadership Elections Coming Next Week

After his surprise announcement to resign from Congress at the end of October, House Speaker John Boehner (R-OH) notified House Republicans this week that new leadership elections will take place next Thursday.

Save Up to $200; Register for Proclaim 16 by the End of the Month

Registration is open for Proclaim 16, the NRB International Christian Media Convention, which will be held February 23-26, 2016, in Nashville, TN. But to take advantage of the Early Bird Registration discounts, you’ll need to register by November 1, 2015.

Louisiana College Inaugurates Dr. Rick Brewer as 9th President

Dr. Rick Brewer was inaugurated as Louisiana College's ninth president last month – six months after Louisiana College trustees unanimously elected him to the position, and five months after he officially took office.

Christian Media Students: Win an iNRB Award!

Did you know that Christian students with an interest or major in broadcasting, journalism, or media communications are not only eligible to join iNRB, but are also able to participate in the annual iNRB contests and competitions for awards, prizes, and scholarships?

In Case You Missed It: Fox News Special on Planned Parenthood’s ‘Hidden Harvest’ Now Online

Fox News has made available online a special report that it aired early last month highlighting the undercover video expose on Planned Parenthood’s fetal tissue business.

John MacArthur Details Mysteries of God’s Kingdom in New Book: Parables

This month, Nelson Books will release the latest book by Pastor John MacArthur, Parables, which attempts to help Christians understand the essential lessons contained in the most famous and influential short stories the world has ever known.

Battle to Respect the Sanctity of Human Life Remains at Center Stage

Most Senate Democrats and two Senate Republicans voted to block legislation that would largely outlaw abortion after 20 weeks of pregnancy, an age at which science is clear that a prenatal child can feel pain.

More News