HOME > NEWSROOM > ARTICLES > Supreme Court Turns Down First Amendment Case

Supreme Court Turns Down First Amendment Case

The U.S. Supreme Court this week decided not to take up Elane Photography v. Willock, a case in which a professional photographer was punished for declining a request to work due to her religious beliefs.  

In 2006, Elaine Huguenin chose not to use her artistic talents for a same-sex commitment ceremony. While the would-be customer, Vanessa Willock, found another photographer, she proceeded to file a complaint with the New Mexico Human Rights Commission. Ultimately, the New Mexico Supreme Court ruled against Elane Photography, dismissing an argument that to photograph such a ceremony violated Mrs. Huguenin’s First Amendment right against compelled speech. In a concurring opinion, one of the New Mexico Supreme Court Justices argued that Mrs. Huguenin needed to compromise in this situation as “the price of citizenship.”

Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF), an NRB Member, represented Elane Photography. After the Supreme Court’s refusal to hear the case, ADF Senior Counsel David Cortman stated, “Elaine and numerous others like her around the country have been more than willing to serve any and all customers, but they are not willing to promote any and all messages. A government that forces any American to create a message contrary to her own convictions is a government every American should fear.”

Another ADF senior counsel, Jordan Lorence, posted in a National Review Online article, “I am concerned that this dark time of viewpoint suppression will get darker before it gets better. Our Founding Fathers gave us the First Amendment to protect people’s freedom of expression and freedom of conscience from these emotional spasms of government coercion. All Americans ought to see this growing threat to our liberty and our First Amendment traditions and speak against it. That is the true ‘price of citizenship.’”

By Aaron Mercer, Vice President of Government Relations

Published: April 11, 2014

Latest News

Christmas Reflections in Washington

While end-of-year debates on government appropriations, military policy, tax provisions, judicial nominations, and other issues continue their rough road to resolution in this lame-duck session of Congress, Christmas is in the air in the nation’s capital.

FCC Rules Against Church on Closed Captioning

The FCC recently denied a church’s request for a waiver from closed captioning rules, shedding more light on the agency’s approach to determining what may truly be an “economically burdensome” situation.

Senator Promises a Bill Broader than ENDA

Senator Jeff Merkley (D-OR) announced this week that he intends to introduce legislation next year that will roll the controversial Employment Non-Discrimination Act (ENDA) into a broader...

White Paper Issued on Video Policy

Key leaders in the House Energy and Commerce Committee this week released a white paper on video policy as they continue their path toward a review and revamp the Communications Act.

NRB15 Worship Service on Wednesday, February 25, 2015; Open to the Public

The NRB Convention in 2015 will be a Monday-to-Thursday event rather than a Saturday-to-Tuesday event as in years before, but convention participants will still have an opportunity to worship together during the Wednesday evening worship service on February 25, 2015.

NRB to Host Regional Networking Event for Christian Film Pros, Jan. 10

Christian film professionals in the Baltimore, DC, and Richmond region are invited to attend a networking event next month at the NRB headquarters in Manassas, VA.

NRB15 Convention Extras: Affiliate Events

For the annual NRB International Christian Media Convention, we’ve brought together more than 60 speakers, nearly 200 exhibitors, dozens of insightful sessions, and various networking events.

NRB Job Opening: Copywriter/Assistant

The National Religious Broadcasters (NRB), the world’s preeminent association of Christian communicators, is looking for a committed, well-established, mature Christian to serve part-time as a copywriter and assistant for the association’s Communications and Conventions divisions.

'Urban Life Issues' to Join 'Life Issues' Radio Lineup

In February 2015, Life Issues Institute will launch Urban Life Issues, an extension of the Life Issues radio broadcast, which airs daily commentary on abortion and related issues on more than 1,100 radio outlets across the nation.

NRB15 Int’l Christian Media Convention to Feature 60+ Speakers

Less than three months remain until thousands of Christian communicators gather in Nashville, TN, for the NRB 2015 International Christian Media Convention.

More News