HOME > NEWSROOM > ARTICLES > Supreme Court Hears Religious Freedom Cases

Supreme Court Hears Religious Freedom Cases

Two faith-based businesses, Hobby Lobby and Conestoga Wood Specialties, had their day before the US Supreme Court this week.  Both businesses have brought a religious freedom challenge against the Obama Administration’s mandate that all new health plans cover contraception, sterilization, and abortion-inducing drugs. 

In this “David and Goliath” struggle against the Executive Branch, Paul Clement, who served as United States Solicitor General under President George W. Bush, argued on behalf of the businesses before the Supreme Court Justices.  The federal government was represented by Donald Verrilli, the current United States Solicitor General. 

A number of the Justices were actively engaged with questions during this oral argument.  Much of the debate centered on the applicability of the 1993 Religious Freedom Restoration Act (RFRA), among other statutes and case law, to these challenges. In particular, the ability of for-profit corporations to exercise religion was under the microscope, as was the existence (or not) of a “compelling interest” for the objectionable Obamacare mandate. 

In one interesting exchange, Justice Anthony Kennedy, often looked at as a “swing vote” on the Court, stated to General Verrilli, “Under your view, a profit corporation could be forced… in principle to pay for abortions.”  The Solicitor General countered, “…there is no law like that on the books. In fact, the law is the opposite.” However, Chief Justice John Roberts quickly jumped in and in the course of questioning highlighted, “Isn't that what we are talking about in terms of their religious beliefs? One of the religious beliefs is that they have to pay for these four methods of contraception that they believe provide abortions. I thought that's what we had before us.”

As private businesses, Hobby Lobby and Conestoga Wood Specialties do not fall under the narrow religious exemption of this federal mandate, so they would be required to include such coverage of abortion-inducing drugs when their health plans renew or face exorbitant and potentially fatal federal fines for their refusal to comply.

NRB highlighted again this week its solidarity with these companies in their religious freedom battle. Notably, the NRB Board of Directors, a body of nearly 100 key leaders in faith-based media, unanimously approved a Resolution last month urging the Supreme Court to uphold the free exercise rights of these two family businesses. The Board also called on NRB members “to pray for the Justices of the United States Supreme Court that they may render just decisions which provide constitutionally sound and robust protections for the exercise of religious freedom in America.” Moreover, NRB’s Office of General Counsel filed an Amicus Curiae (“Friend of the Court”) brief in this case arguing for appropriate “breathing room” for religious freedom.

A decision from the Supreme Court is expected by the end of June.

By Aaron Mercer, Vice President of Government Relations

Published: March 28, 2014

Latest News

NRB Concerned by Call for Hate Speech Proceeding

A petition to the FCC challenging a broadcaster license alleges “hate speech” and calls for a FCC hearing on the subject. Dr. Jerry A. Johnson, President & CEO of NRB, wrote to FCC Chairman Tom Wheeler to...

City of Houston Subpoenas Sermons

NRB and many others were alarmed this week by the City of Houston’s subpoena of local pastors’ church sermons. “This inquisition by the City of Houston is unconstitutional,” declared Dr. Jerry A. Johnson, President & CEO of NRB.

Thousands Gather to Pray for Washington

On Columbus Day, I was pleased to gather with thousands of Christians from churches around the Washington, DC area to pray for this capital city.

FCC Calls for Input on LPTV

The FCC recently declared that it is suspending deadlines for construction of new digital low power television (LPTV) stations, and similarly stated its intent to postpone the 2015 deadline for...

NRB to Debut Film & Entertainment Summit in 2015

NRB is launching the Film & Entertainment Summit at the NRB 2015 International Christian Media Convention in Nashville, TN.

Don't Miss Early Bird Rates for the NRB15 Int’l Christian Media Convention!

Registration is open for the NRB 2015 International Christian Media Convention, to be held February 23-26, 2015, in Nashville, TN. But to take advantage of the Early Bird Registration discounts and save up to $200, you’ll need to register by November 15, 2014.

NRB Digital Media Summit to Return in 2015 Bigger and Better

After an incredibly successful debut earlier this year, the NRB Digital Media Summit will be returning in 2015 with a star-studded list of speakers who excel in Web, mobile, social media, and content strategy.

Renewing Your Mind with R.C. Sproul Celebrates 20 Years on Air

Dr. R.C. Sproul and Ligonier Ministries are celebrating two decades of Renewing Your Mind on the radio.

ERLC to Host National Conference on Homosexuality and the Future of Marriage: Oct. 27-29

The Ethics & Religious Liberty Commission of the Southern Baptist Convention is set to host a national conference on the issue of homosexuality and the future of marriage later this month at the Opryland Hotel in Nashville, TN.

Chip Ingram’s Living on the Edge Ministry Joins Effort to Reach U.S. Prisoners

Living on the Edge recently got behind an effort to stream ministry materials and audio files to prisoners throughout the United States by providing audio content from the ministry’s CEO & Teaching Pastor, Chip Ingram.

More News