HOME > NEWSROOM > ARTICLES > NRB Warns Against Senate Proposal to Limit First Amendment Freedoms


NRB Warns Against Senate Proposal to Limit First Amendment Freedoms

Statue of Liberty muzzledThe United States Senate is considering an amendment to the U.S. Constitution that could have serious repercussions for First Amendment freedoms.  While proponents of the amendment are lauding it as a move toward campaign finance reform, Dr. Jerry A. Johnson, President & CEO of NRB, called it “convoluted” and “unacceptable,” and warned it would be “detrimental to liberty and equality, preparing the way for the government to prefer one voice over another – or to suppress one voice under another.” 

NRB is not alone in its alarm at this proposal.  In a hearing on the constitutional amendment this week before the Senate Judiciary Committee, Senator Chuck Grassley (R-IA), the top Republican on the panel, laid out a powerful case against the amendment starting with the foundational principles of unalienable rights found in the Declaration of Independence. He emphasized, “The Bill of Rights protects individual rights regardless of whether the government or a majority approves of their use.”  Regarding the subject of the hearing, Senator Grassley stated:

Today, freedom of speech is threatened as it has not been in many decades.  Too many people are impatient and will not listen and debate and persuade.  They want to punish, intimidate, and silence those with whom they disagree…. S.J. Res. 19, cut from the same cloth, would amend the Constitution for the first time to diminish an important right of Americans that is contained in the Bill of Rights.  In fact, it would cut back on the most important of these rights, core free speech about who should be elected to govern ourselves. 

Similarly, Senator Ted Cruz (R-TX) was outspoken in opposition to this effort.  In a Wall Street Journal editorial warning of the free speech threats of this bill, Senator Cruz declared, “The contemplated amendment is simply wrong. No politician should be immune from criticism. Congress has too much power already—it should never have the power to silence citizens.”  He concluded, “Sen. Ted Kennedy was right to say: ‘In the entire history of the Constitution, we have never amended the Bill of Rights, and now is no time to start.’”

This week’s hearing was significant not only because of the subject matter, but also due to the rare presence of Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-NV) and Republican Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY) on the same panel to testify for and against the constitutional amendment.  Senator Reid declared, “a constitutional amendment is what this nation needs to bring sanity back to political campaigns and restore Americans’ confidence in their elected leaders….Free speech shouldn’t cost the American voter a dime.”  However, Senator McConnell countered, “[T]he political nature of this exercise should not obscure how shockingly bad this proposal is. When it comes to free speech, we shouldn’t substitute the incumbent-protection desires of politicians for the protection the Constitution guarantees to all Americans.”

Senator Tom Udall (D-NM) last summer introduced this proposed constitutional amendment (S.J.Res.19). Thus far, 43 Senate Democrats, including Majority Leader Harry Reid, have stated public support for this bill. Amendments to the U.S. Constitution require 2/3 support in both the House and the Senate, and then ratification by 3/4 of the States.

In a letter to the Chairman and to the Ranking Member of the Senate Judiciary Committee, Dr. Johnson wrote, “[T]his political exercise could be starting a dangerous proceeding – one which may well ultimately call into question the basic First Amendment freedoms of all Americans.  The text of this proposed Constitutional Amendment is unacceptable, and I urge you to reject any attempt to advance it.”

  • Read Dr. Johnson’s letter highlighting key concerns with this proposed constitutional amendment.
  • Find video and written testimony from this Senate Judiciary Committee hearing.
  • See the full text of S.J.Res.19.

By Aaron Mercer,
Vice President of Government Relations

Published: June 5 , 2014

Latest News

NRB Hosts Debate on Homosexuality at Int'l Christian Media Convention

A diverse panel at the National Religious Broadcasters’ International Christian Media Convention examined the issue of homosexuality last Thursday at a public policy session titled “Cultural Controversy Through the Lens of Scripture: What does the Bible say about homosexuality?”

Israeli Prime Minister Addresses Congress

Earlier this week, at the invitation of Speaker of the House John Boehner (R-OH), Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu spoke to a joint session of Congress on Israel’s relationship with the United States and the threat of Iran.

Conflict Embedded in Youth Runaway Bill

Last week the Senate Judiciary Committee approved two bills aimed at combatting human trafficking in the United States.

Legislation Against Performance Tax Gathers Steam

While last month the U.S. Copyright Office unsurprisingly reiterated its longtime call for new performance royalty payments to be levied against radio broadcasters, many Members of Congress have again certified that they don’t agree with a performance tax.

Alan Robertson, Benham Brothers Discuss Free Speech Concerns at NRB15

Alan Robertson of Duck Dynasty joined would-be HGTV stars David and Jason Benham on a panel at the NRB15 International Christian Media Convention in Nashville, TN, to discuss defending free speech.

In Memoriam: Pro-Life Pioneer Dr. John C. Willke

Dr. John C. (Jack) Willke, President of Life Issues Institute, passed away unexpectedly at his home in Cincinnati, OH, on Friday, February 20, at the age of 89.

Israel Tourism Minister Calls for More ‘Watchmen’ to Defend Judeo-Christian Values

Israel Tourism Minister Dr. Uzi Landau is urging all Christians to step forward as “watchmen” of Judeo-Christian values, which are being threatened in the Middle East by organizations including Al-Qaeda, Hezbollah, ISIS, the Muslim Brotherhood, Hamas, and more.

More than 4,300 Attend NRB15:Proclaim Int’l Christian Media Convention

More than 4,300 media and ministry professionals from across the nation and around the world gathered February 23-26 for the National Religious Broadcasters' 2015 International Christian Media Convention in Nashville, TN.

SBC President: Church Needs to ‘Wake Up,’ Seek ‘Extraordinary Prayer’ for Revival

There is a dangerous collision of worldviews, yet Christians are slumbering, Southern Baptist Convention President Dr. Ronnie Floyd told attendees at a worship service hosted last Wednesday by the National Religious Broadcasters.

Barna Urges NRB to Influence Conservatives Politically

Pollster George Barna urged communicators at the NRB15 International Christian Media Convention in Nashville, TN, to use their sizable influence to guide conservatives politically at a time when the nation needs to return to biblical values.

More News