HOME > NEWSROOM > ARTICLES > ‘Ministry of Truth’ Case Before High Court

'Ministry of Truth' Case Before High Court

An attorney for a pro-life organization, as well as a U.S. Supreme Court Justice, recently invoked the ominous image of George Orwell’s 1984  “Ministry of Truth” during a recent oral argument before the High Court. In a fight against an Ohio law to prohibit “false statements” during political campaigns, pro-life Susan B. Anthony (SBA) List’s lawyer, Michael Carvin, declared, “Our constitutional claim here is the ministry of truth has no ability to judge our political speech as falsity.” 

SBA List’s case originated after then-Congressman Steve Driehaus (D-OH) filed a complaint with the Ohio Election Commission in 2010 that the pro-life group was lying about his record when it was preparing billboard ads to highlight his vote in support of the Affordable Care Act (also known as “Obamacare”) as one authorizing use of taxpayer funds for abortion. A panel of the commission found “probable cause” of a false statement and referred the complaint to the full commission. However, the proceeding ended after Rep. Driehaus lost his election and dropped the complaint.

The question before the Supreme Court in Susan B. Anthony List v. Driehaus began as one of standing for an organization that had not felt the brunt of the Ohio law (fines and possibly imprisonment).  However, the Justices clearly were interested in the underlying constitutional issue.  Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg pointedly observed, “[W]hat about the harm that is occurring? …They're brought before the commission, they have to answer this charge that they lied…. just that alone is going to diminish the effect of their speech because they have been labeled false speakers, and it costs money to defend before the commission, right?” Justice Elena Kagan similarly stated, “There are voters out there… [who] think probable cause means you probably lied, and that seems a reasonable thing for them to think… we don't even need the prosecution to serve as the relevant harm. That seems quite enough.” On the other end of the Court’s spectrum, Justice Antonin Scalia also showed concern, stating, “The mere fact that a private individual can chill somebody's speech does not say, well, since a private individual can do it, you know, the ministry of truth can do it.”

If the Supreme Court rules in favor of SBA List’s standing claim, it will overturn a Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals decision against the pro-life group.  The organization would then be able to begin court proceedings challenging the substance of the Ohio law.  Prior to the oral argument, SBA List President Marjorie Dannenfelser declared, “Free speech is the qualifier for any argument, including our argument, abortion. If we can’t take that for granted, then we have no ability to argue that abortion is the taking of the life of a person equal to you and me.”

By Aaron Mercer, Vice President of Government Relations

Published: May 2, 2014

Latest News

Religious Freedom in Focus in Marriage Case

This week the U.S. Supreme Court heard oral arguments in Obergefell v. Hodges, a case pivotal for the future of marriage in the United States.

Senator Introduces Resolution to Nullify Net Neutrality Order

U.S. Senator Rand Paul (R-KY) took aim at the FCC’s controversial net neutrality order this week.

NRB Urges Iran Bill to Require Release of Americans

This week the Senate has been debating the Iran Nuclear Agreement Review Act, which would give Congress an opportunity to weigh in for or against any deal the Executive Branch reaches with Iran over its nuclear program.

RFRA Highlighted on Senate Floor

In the wake of attacks on religious freedom, Senator Orrin Hatch (R-UT) took to the Senate Floor this week to defend this constitutional right.

Urgent Need for Aid, Prayer in Aftermath of Nepal Quake

Members of the National Religious Broadcasters have sprung into action and into prayer in the aftermath of the devastating 7.8-magnitude earthquake that struck Nepal on Saturday.

64th Annual Observance of the National Day of Prayer on Thursday, May 7

Next Thursday, millions will assemble at thousands of local National Day of Prayer events across the nation, taking time out of their daily schedules to intercede on behalf of their communities, their nation, and their leaders.

Life-Changing Gift Ideas for Mother’s Day 2015

Each year, a number of Christian nonprofits produce and present gift catalogs with ideas that will not only honor mothers on Mother’s Day but also improve the lives of poverty-stricken children, mothers, and families that struggle to survive in developing countries.

LifeWay Christian Resources Paving Way for New HQ

LifeWay Christian Resources is planning to build a new facility, and recently entered into a contract for the sale of their main campus in downtown Nashville.

Thousands of Churches to Join ‘Stand for Marriage Sunday’ on April 26

Thousands of churches will join “Stand for Marriage Sunday” on April 26 – just two days before the U.S. Supreme Court hears oral arguments on the definition of marriage.

House Panel to Review FCC Transparency Proposals

Congressman Greg Walden (R-OR), Chairman of the House Communications and Technology Subcommittee, has scheduled a hearing next Thursday on “FCC Reauthorization: Improving Commission Transparency.”

More News